Contrast and Concession
Learning objectives
- Choose contrast forms by emotion and register.
- Avoid the accusatory force of くせに in neutral contexts.
- Compare a result with an expected standard using にしては.
予想
よそう
nounexpectation; prediction
不満
ふまん
noundissatisfaction
評価
ひょうか
nounevaluation
経験
けいけん
nounexperience
意外
いがい
adjunexpected
認める
みとめる
verbto acknowledge
Contrast has a tone
plain + のに
emotionalalthough; despite
Marks an unexpected result, often with disappointment, surprise, or complaint.
予約したのに、三十分も待たされた。
Although I had booked, I was made to wait thirty minutes.
V-ても/Nでも
neutraleven if; even though
Concedes a real or hypothetical condition without necessarily expressing blame.
雨が降っても、試合は行われます。
Even if it rains, the match will be held.
stem/N/adj + ながらも
writtenalthough; while acknowledging
A compact, often written way to recognise one fact before presenting a contrasting fact.
小さいながらも、設備が整っている。
Although it is small, it is well equipped.
plain + くせに
criticaleven though; despite
Expresses criticism, contempt, or blame. Avoid it toward superiors and in neutral explanation.
知っているくせに、何も教えてくれなかった。
Even though they knew, they told me nothing.
N/plain + にしては
evaluationfor; considering
The result differs from the standard normally expected for that category or situation.
初めてにしては、よくできました。
For a first attempt, you did well.
Do not soften a complaint with くせに
新人なのに詳しい expresses surprise. 新人のくせに偉そうだ attacks the person for acting contrary to the speaker’s expectation. The second form is deliberately harsh.
Match the contrast to the intended attitude.
1.Neutral rule: the event proceeds even if it snows.
2.Written acknowledgement: the device is old but still useful.
3.Positive evaluation: the report is good for a beginner.
A small hotel with a strong reputation
travel review
- 旅館(りょかん)
- Japanese inn
- 手入れ(ていれ)
- care; maintenance
- What two positive contrasts are described?
- What expectation does にしては establish?
A disappointing purchase
Listen for the speaker's emotional contrast.
- Which form carries disappointment?
- 1のに often carries emotion; ても gives neutral concession.
- 2ながらも acknowledges two sides in compact written style.
- 3くせに is critical; にしては compares reality with an expected standard.
Knowledge Check
約束した__、来なかった。
約束した__、来なかった。
- Aのに
- Bにしては
- Cさえ
- D結果
忙しく__、毎日運動します。
- Aても
- Bくせに
- Cにしては
- Dことから
Which sounds openly critical?
- A知らないのに
- B知らなくても
- C知らないくせに
- D知らないにしては
新人__、対応が落ち着いている。
- Aの結果
- Bにしては
- Cさえ
- Dそうだ
Which is suited to balanced written contrast?
- A狭いながらも快適だ。
- B狭いくせに快適だ。
- C狭さえ快適だ。
- D狭い結果快適だ。
Why is くせに risky with a superior?
- AIt is too formal
- BIt conveys criticism or contempt
- CIt means praise
- DIt can only describe weather
Even if it is expensive, I need it: 高く__、必要だ。
- Aのに
- Bても
- Cくせに
- Dにしては
Which sentence evaluates against a category expectation?
- A冬なのに暖かい。
- B冬でも行く。
- C冬にしては暖かい。
- D冬のくせに暖かい。